Most Rare Old Coins - Search Shopping

Compare Products

Choose upto 5 items for side by side feature comparison

Wishlist

Go to collections

Show filters

Shop Most Rare Old Coins

Sponsored

Lady Liberty Gold 1/20Th Ounce Ro…

$265.01

Money Metals Ex…

Rare Bicentennial Quarter Dollar US…

$2,000.00

eBay.com

Gold And Silver Kennedy Half Doll…

$9.95

Danbury Mint

Used

EXTREMELY RARE 1973 Penny Rare …

$1,800.00

eBay

1979-Wide RIM P Susan B. Anthon…

Liberty Sacagawea 1 US Dollar

PRESIDENTIAL DOLLAR COIN 1…

1776-1976 Eisenhower Libert…

VERY RARE1980 D Wide Rim Near D…

RARE ERROR 2021 P Washingt…

$1,991.42

eBay

$20 U.S. Liberty Gold Coins, Clean…

$3,843.73

Money Metals Ex…

Used

Extremely RARE 1964 D Jefferson …

$2,000.00

eBay

Used

1972 Rare Lincoln Cent DDO DDR

$2,000.00

eBay

Used

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

$2,500.00

eBay.com

Used

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

$250.00

eBay.com

Free shipping

RARE 1944 Wheat Penny

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

$2,500.00

eBay.com

Used

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

$250.00

eBay.com

Free shipping

RARE 1944 Wheat Penny

Abraham Lincoln Penny 1969 S An…

1995 No Mint Collectors Uniqu…

RARE 1967 Circulated Washin…

$1,000.00

eBay

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

1936 F Buffalo Nickel

$449.99

eBay.com

1944 Lincoln Wheat Penny D- Erro. Li…

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

Lincoln Penny 1982 1982 D Transitional

$2,400.00

eBay

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

1969 Elisabeth 11 10 Pence

$100.00

Etsy

5.0

Showing 1 - 36 out of 167 results for "most rare old coins"
Sort by:
Featured
Featured
Price - High To Low
Price - Low To High
1. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 C…
  $1,500.00
  E
  eBay
  Free shipping
2. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  4.8
  ·
  25
  4.8
  25 ratings
  Extremely Rare 1932 D Washingto…
  $299.95
  E
  Etsy
3. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Very Very Rare Old Coin
  $199.00
  E
  eBay
4. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Rare Coin
  $2,500.00
  E
  eBay
5. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare Coins
  $607.16
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
6. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare 1944 Wheat Penny
  $35.00
  E
  Etsy
7. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Rare 1920 "Woody" Error Coin Linc…
  $15.00
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
8. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  1963 D Penny (Rare)
  $250.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
9. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  1916 No Mint Wheat Penny - Rare
  $245.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
10. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  SALE
  4.7
  ·
  48
  4.7
  48 ratings
  1937 D 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel Coi…
  $25.16
  $50.08
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
11. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  5
  ·
  4
  5
  4 ratings
  Very Rare 1883 Hawaiian Dollar Coi…
  $37.71
  E
  Etsy
12. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Extremely Rare Coin 20 Cents Spai…
  $425.74
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
13. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  4.4
  ·
  7
  4.4
  7 ratings
  Rare John F. Kennedy Half-Dollar 1…
  $929.78
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
14. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare 1940 Wheat Penny
  $100.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
15. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  1776-1976 EISENHOWER LIBERT…
  $4,800.00
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
16. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  1943 Lincoln P Wheat Steal Penny …
  $2,400.00
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
17. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Rare 1971 Eisenhower Liberty Dolla…
  $25.00
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
18. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  RARE 1964 D Nickel DD Errors
  $750.00
  E
  eBay
  Free shipping
19. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare 1944 Wheat Penny
  $399.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
20. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare US Coins
  $59.95
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
21. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare 1950 No Mint Mark Wheat Pen…
  $450.00
  E
  Etsy
22. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Very Rare 1917 Error Wheat Penny …
  $80.00
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
23. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  1965 Quarter - Rare Hard To Find
  $225.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
24. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  1776-1976 D Msrk Washington Qua…
  $169.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
25. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Rare Coin
  $600.00
  E
  Etsy
26. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare 1948 No Mint Wheat Penny
  $75.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
27. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  4.6
  ·
  12
  4.6
  12 ratings
  Rare 1943 Steel Wheat Penny One …
  $2,100.00
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
28. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  5
  ·
  2
  5
  2 ratings
  1776-1976 D Mark - Washington Qu…
  $250.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
29. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 C…
  $19.99
  E
  Etsy
30. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  5
  ·
  1
  Rare Classic Coins Collection
  $49.95
  Q
  QVC
31. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  5
  ·
  1
  Rare 1942 Major Off Center Lincoln …
  $349.95
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
32. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Susan B Anthony Rare 1979 One D…
  $250.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
33. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Valuable PCGS, NGC, ANAC Old U…
  $1,249.00
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
34. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Rare 1942 Wheat Penny With Missi…
  $300.00
  E
  Etsy
35. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  5
  ·
  3
  5
  3 ratings
  1987 No Mint Rare Penny
  $50.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
36. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Lincoln Wheat No Mint Super Rare.…
  $744.33
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
Oops! We are sorry, something went wrong.
Continue your shopping by clicking on another product
Product added to your wishlist! View wishlist
Sign in to see your saved products on any device
Product removed from your wishlist! View wishlist
Sign in to see your saved products on any device
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Product is added to compare already. Please refresh the page.
Product is not found in compare. Please refresh the page.
5 Products already added. Please delete existing selection to add this.
Sponsored
✕
Learn how your ads are chosen
ebay.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Ebay Core
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
www.ebay.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: RedBrain Limited
Location: United Kingdom
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
moneymetals.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
The gender you selected in your Microsoft account and your search history
The birthdate you shared in your Microsoft account and your search history
Advertiser Details
Name: Money Metals Exchange
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
Ad settings
Used
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…
$2,000.00
eBay
Free shipping
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…
$600.00
eBay.com
Free shipping
Used
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…
$799.00
eBay.com
Used
Very Rare ( 1959 ERROR Penny ) …
$1,800.00
eBay
$10 U.S. Liberty Gold Coins, Clean…
$1,959.76
Money Metals Ex…
Rare 2000 D Sacagawea One …
$589.00
eBay.com
Free shipping
Lady Liberty Gold 1/100Th Ounce R…
$60.41
Money Metals Ex…
5.0
·
3
Used
1776-1976 D US Bicentennial Quar…
$500.00
US eBay
Free shipping
Used
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…
$550.00
eBay
Free shipping
Used
Very Very Rare Old Coins
$3,500.00
eBay
Penny Coins Us Rare
$300.00
eBay
Very Rare 1980 Susan B Anthony …
$295.00
eBay
Collectors...Rare 1971 S Lincoln Pe…
$335.80
eBay
Used
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…
$900.00
eBay
Free shipping
Rare Penny
$200.00
eBay
Used
VERY RARE 1980 SUSAN B ANTH…
$400.00
eBay
1944 Very Rare Wheat Penny
$400.00
eBay
Beautiful 1969 S Double Die Lincol…
$450.00
eBay.com
3.0
·
2
Used
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…
$250.00
eBay
Free shipping
Used
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…
$5,000.00
eBay.com
5.0
·
3
- Vintage Coins - Coins of America
  https://coinsofamerica.com
  Small business
  SponsoredProfessional & accurate details in our educational tri-fold two coin collections. Easy to use website with fast, secure checkout.
- Now: Rare Collectable Coins | Rare Collectable Coins
  https://cheaper99.com › Rare Collectable Coins
  Free Shipping
  SponsoredBest Deals On Rare Collectable Coins. Enjoy Discounts & Hottest Sales On Rare Collectable Coins. Limited Offer. Shop Now!
  Site visitors: Over 100K in the past month
  Top Ratings · Popular Deals · Exclusive Deals · Compare prices
  Types: Beauty and Health, Books, Electronics, Fashion, Shoes, Toys and more
  - All categories ·
  - Only Auctions ·
  - Without Auctions ·
  - Great offers
- 10 Best Rare Coins of 2025 - American Coin Treasures 2025
  https://10best.how
  SponsoredFind what is perfect for you. Fast & Easy. Best Guide and Products. High Quality.
  Wow · Explore · Just For You · Easy
  - Top Rated ·
  - Best Computers ·
  - Best ·
  - Best Tablets
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5

Brand

Price

Material

Seller

Shop Most Rare Old Coins

Vintage Coins - Coins of America

Now: Rare Collectable Coins | Rare Collectable Coins

10 Best Rare Coins of 2025 - American Coin Treasures 2025